Police complaints Statistics for England and Wales (plain text format) - 2023/24

Each year, we publish statistics about the complaints that forces have logged. We also produce quarterly bulletins for all police forces.

Read our Director General’s release - 

Contents

 


Introduction

This report presents figures on complaints about the police in England and Wales for 2023/24. These complaints are made by members of the public about the service they have received from a police force. They are handled under the Police Reform Act 2002, as amended by the Policing and Crime Act 2017.


The Policing and Crime Act 2017 and supporting regulations made significant changes to the police complaints and disciplinary systems. These changes were designed to achieve a simpler, more proportionate, and customer-focused complaints system focused on learning and improvement. The changes were implemented on 1 February 2020 with the British Transport Police falling under the new legislation from 4 January 2021.


A police complaint is an expression of dissatisfaction by a member of the public about the service they have received from a police force. Police forces and local policing bodies deal with the majority of complaints themselves. The IOPC sets the standards for complaints handling through its Statutory Guidance 2020

Statutory Guidance helps local policing bodies and forces achieve high standards in handling complaints about the police. It also helps them to comply with their legal obligations. The IOPC oversees the complaints system and investigates the most serious and sensitive cases. It also carries out reviews of some complaints.


The first stage of complaint handling is for the relevant police force or local policing body to decide how it will handle the complaint. Legislation allows for certain types of complaints to be resolved informally, while allowing more flexibility in the formal handling of complaints. This allows the police to better meet the needs of the complainant, and quickly make improvements based on the complaints they handle.


A person can request a review if they are unhappy with the way their complaint was handled or the outcome. In some instances, this review will be carried out by the IOPC. Other reviews are handled by local policing bodies (Police and Crime Commissioners and Mayors).
 

Most of the data referred to in this report was recorded on police force IT systems and collected by the IOPC. While data has undergone quality assurance checks, the statistics remain under evaluation until their quality, including their accuracy, reliability, and their value, is established and verified. Therefore they should be treated as experimental1 to acknowledge that they should be interpreted with some caution and that further development and evaluation is currently taking place.


We have given police forces guidance setting out how we expect them to record the data we collect. Therefore, the consistency of the data we report relies on police forces applying our guidance correctly when they record data.


Our guidance on how police forces should record data about complaints under the Police Reform Act 2002, as amended by the Policing and Crime Act 2017, is available on our website: www.policeconduct.gov.uk.

 


Findings

Initial handling of complaints and how long it takes

Complaint cases logged

The Policing and Crime Act 2017 and supporting regulations made significant changes to the complaints system, widening the definition of a complaint to make the system more accessible. This means many more complaints will now be logged than in previous years.


The definition of a police complaint is an expression of dissatisfaction by a member of the public about the service they have received from a police force. All expressions of dissatisfaction must be logged. Some dissatisfaction, which does not meet the criteria for recording a complaint under Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002, may be resolved quickly to the satisfaction of the complainant. Other expressions of dissatisfaction must be recorded.

  • In 2023/24, police forces and local policing bodies logged 85,458 complaint cases (table 1) – a 5% increase on 2022/23.
  • Forces took on average five working days to log complaints from the date the complaint was made (table 3).
  • Most forces (32 out of 44) logged complaints in an average of five working days or less.

There are considerable differences in the size of police forces across England and Wales. This impacts the number of complaint cases logged by forces. Direct comparison of the number of complaint cases across forces would not take into account these size variations.

A complaint cases rate per 1,000 police force employees is used to provide a meaningful comparison of complaints logged across forces.

  • In 2023/24, 338 complaint cases per 1,000 employees across all forces were logged (table 2) – an increase of 9 complaints per 1,000 employees compared to 2022/23.
  • Complaint case rates per 1,000 employees ranged from 96 in Norfolk to 812 in Cleveland Police.

Time taken to contact the complainant

When handling complaints, the body responsible must contact the complainant and seek their views about how the complaint should be handled. This should happen as soon as possible after the complaint is made.

  • In 2023/24, forces took an average of six working days from the date the complaint was made to contact the complainant (table 3), one day longer than 2022/23.
  • The time forces took to contact complainants ranged from an average of one day in five forces to 28 days in City of London and Devon & Cornwall (table 3).

Recording complaints

Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002 sets out legal requirements for police complaint handling.

A complaint does not need to be formally recorded under Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002 if it can be resolved quickly and to the satisfaction of the complainant. Even if attempts are made to initially handle the complaint outside of the requirements of Schedule 3, it may later be recorded and handled under Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002. Information about recording complaints is available in Chapter 6 of our Statutory Guidance (2020).

There are four reasons why a complaint must be recorded under Schedule 3:

  • the complainant wants it to be recorded
  • the nature of the allegation(s) mean it must be recorded
  • the appropriate authority/body responsible for initial handling decides it is appropriate
  • the complainant is dissatisfied following informal handling

Reasons complaint cases recorded under Schedule 3 in 2023/24

  • A total of 32,511 complaint cases logged in 2023/24 were subsequently recorded under Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002 - a 3% increase on 2022/23 (table 4).
  • In 43% (13,962) of cases, the body responsible for the initial handling of the complaint decided it should be recorded.
  • Just under a quarter (21%, 6,808) of complaints were recorded because the complainant wanted it to be recorded.
  • 21% (6,962) of complaint cases were recorded due to the nature of the allegations made.
  • In 15% (4,779) of cases, the complainant was dissatisfied with the informal handling and requested their complaint be recorded.
  • There is variation across forces on the reasons for recording complaints under Schedule 3. In six forces, 50% or more of the complaints they recorded were because the person who complained wanted it to be recorded. In 15 forces, 50% or more of complaints were recorded because the body responsible for initial handling decided to do so.

Reasons complaint cases recorded under Schedule 3 in 2023/24 by category:

  • 43% body responsible for initial handling decides
  • 21% complainant wishes the complaint to be recorded
  • 21% nature of allegation(s)
  • 15% dissatisfaction after informal handling

What complaints were about

A complaint case may include one or more allegations. Each allegation is allocated to one of 11 categories and a subcategory if applicable. The purpose of the categories is to capture the root of the dissatisfaction expressed in a complaint.

  • In 2023/24, 151,539 allegations were logged (table 5).
  • The three most commonly logged allegation categories in 2023/24 were:
    • delivery of duties and service (53%)
    • police powers, policies and procedures (21%)
    • individual behaviours (13%)

These three categories account for 87% of all allegations logged (figure 2).

  • Discriminatory behaviour made up 3% (4,575) of all allegations logged. 50% (2,279) of these were allegations of race discrimination, 18% (838) were about disability, and 14% (645) were about sex discrimination.

Allegations logged in 2023/24 by category.

  • 55% delivery of duties and service
  • 21% police powers, policies and procedures
  • 13% individual behaviours
  • 3% discriminatory behaviours
  • 3% handling of or damage to property/premises
  • 6% all other categories

Who complains and who is subject to complaints

Who makes the complaints

In 2023/24, 79,041 people complained about the police.

  • Most complainants were men (49%, 32,166) (table 8).
  • Where known, most complainants were White (56%, 43,915). It should be noted the ethnicity of 31% (24,647) of complainants was either not stated, unknown or the complainant preferred not to say (table 9).
  • The most common age groups to complain about the police were those aged 30 to 39 years (22%, 17,189 complainants), closely followed by those aged 40 to 49 years (20%, 15,458). The people who complained least commonly were aged 17 or under. However, caution is advised when looking at the breakdown by age owing to 16% (12,581) of complainants whose age is unknown (table 10).

Who is complained about

In 2023/24, 56,410 people serving with the police were subject to a complaint.

  • 61% (34,512) of those complained about were men and 33% (18,565) were women (table 11).
  • Most people subject to a complaint were White (81%, 45,150). However, caution is advised when looking at the breakdown by ethnicity due to the number of subjects (14%, 7,563) with unknown or not stated ethnicity (table 12).

 


Time taken to informally handle a complaint and the outcomes

Informal complaint handling is an opportunity to address promptly the concerns raised by the complainant. The key consideration is whether a course of action is appropriate and whether it will be an effective response to a complaint.

Allegations finalised

An allegation is considered finalised when the complainant is notified about the outcome of the allegation (a decision) and any planned action.

  • In 2023/24, police forces finalised 60,166 allegations on complaint cases that were handled informally (42%) (table 14).
  • On average, these allegations took 18 working days to finalise (table 15). This is two days more than in 2022/23.

Allegation decisions

Where a complaint case is handled informally, the allegation decision will be ‘resolved’ or ‘not resolved’.

  • In 2023/24, 93% of allegations handled informally were recorded as resolved. This means that they were either resolved to the satisfaction of the complainant and/or the complainant did not wish to pursue their complaint formally (table 19).
  • The remaining 7% could not be resolved and will either have been recorded under Schedule 3 or withdrawn by the complainant.

Complaint cases finalised

A complaint case is finalised when all actions relating to that case are complete

  • In 2023/24, 50,594 complaint cases were finalised informally (table 20).
  • These complaint cases took an average of 20 working days to finalise (table 21). This is longer than the 18 working days taken to handle allegations as it includes the time to complete all the actions on the case.

Actions

Any actions taken in response to the allegation are recorded; multiple actions can be recorded for each allegation.

  • The most common action resulting from complaints handled informally was an explanation. 59% of complaint cases finalised resulted in an explanation being given to the complainant (table 22).
  • 14% of complaint cases finalised informally had at least one allegation resulting in no further action (table 22). This is a reduction of seven percentage points from 2022/23.
  • Different types of learning can be selected as the outcome of complaints. These are organisational learning and learning from reflection. These amount to 3% of the outcomes.
  • Actions such as providing an apology or conducting a debrief accounted for a further 11%.
  • Therefore, some sort of learning/reflective activity accounted for the outcome in 14% of cases (table 22).

 


Time taken to formally handle a complaint and the outcomes

All complaints recorded formally should be handled in a reasonable and proportionate manner. This may mean: 

  • an investigation
  • otherwise responding to concerns raised and seeking to resolve them
  • notifying the complainant that no further action will be taken
     

Allegations finalised

An allegation is considered finalised when the complainant is notified about the outcome of the allegation (a decision) and any planned action.

  • In 2023/24, police forces finalised 82,492 allegations on complaint cases handled formally (table 14).

Allegations handled by investigation

If an allegation is investigated, the investigation will fall into one of three types: local, directed, or independent. Please see Glossary for an explanation of the different forms of investigation.

If at any time during an investigation, the investigating officer thinks a person complained about may have

  • committed a criminal offence; or
  • behaved in a manner which would justify the bringing of disciplinary proceedings

the investigation must be certified as subject to ‘special procedures’ (see explanation of ‘special procedures’ in Glossary).

  • In 2023/24, 23% of the 82,492 allegations handled under Schedule 3 were investigated (table 14).
  • 10% of those (1,959 out of 18,860) were finalised by investigations subject to special procedures (table 16).
  • Of allegations handled formally, the proportion investigated ranged from 2% in South Yorkshire Police to 98% in Thames Valley Police.
  • Allegations finalised by local investigation took on average around 191 working days, 32 working days longer than in 2022/23.

Allegations handled otherwise than by investigation

Most allegations will not need a full investigation to reach a conclusion and a decision.

  • In 2023/24, the majority (77%) of allegations handled formally were finalised otherwise than by investigation (table 14).
  • These allegations took forces 106 working days on average to finalise (table 15).

Allegation decisions

Often a complaint case will contain several different allegations. Some may be subject to special procedures and others not. It is possible to handle all allegations in the same way. As such, a complaint case that is investigated subject to special procedures may contain non-special procedures allegations and the decision will reflect this.

  • It was found there was a case to answer for misconduct or gross misconduct in 26% of allegations investigated subject to special procedures (table 19).
  • 42% of allegations investigated subject to special procedures found no case to answer for misconduct or gross misconduct (table 19).
  • 4% found that the service provided was not acceptable (table 19).
  • The remaining allegations investigated subject to special procedures found that either the service was acceptable (or unable to determine), no further action was taken, or the complaint was withdrawn (table 19).
  • It was found the service provided was acceptable in over two-thirds (71%) of allegations investigated where special procedures did not apply (table 19).
  • The service provided was acceptable in the majority (67%) of the allegations finalised formally that were not investigated (table 19).

Complaint cases finalised

A complaint case is considered finalised when all actions relating to that case are complete. This includes:

  • the time during which an application to review can be made
  • the time it takes to deal with a review
  • the time it takes for actions resulting from a recommendation or direction, made either following an investigation or consideration of a review, to be completed
  • the time for the actions arising from a reflective practice review process (RPRP) meeting to be communicated to the complainant or their representative
  • the time it takes for misconduct and/or criminal proceedings to conclude
  • the time for initial outcomes of unsatisfactory performance procedures to be decided

In 2023/24, a total of 31,182 complaint cases were finalised formally (table 20).

  • It took an average of almost six months (133 working days) to finalise complaint cases formally in 2023/24 (table 21) (excluding time spent suspended due to criminal matters).
  • The average time forces took to finalise complaint cases formally ranged from 62 in Sussex to 335 working days in Lancashire. British Transport Police took the shortest amount of time at 61 working days (table 21).

Actions

  • Of the 31,182 complaint cases handled formally in 2023/24, 30% had at least one allegation resulting in no further action being taken (table 23). Previous data collections identified that this action was being recorded incorrectly in some forces and in 2023/24 there was a decrease in the proportion of cases resulting in no further action (40% in 2022/23).
  • 141 complaint cases that were handled formally and subject to a special procedures investigation had at least one allegation resulting in either misconduct meeting or hearing (table 23).
  • 13% of complaint cases had at least one allegation resulting in learning for either the individual or the police force (table 23).
  • 3% (881) of complaint cases handled formally had at least one allegation resulting in a referral to RPRP (table 23).
  • 7% of complaint cases had at least one allegation resulting in an apology or debrief taking place (table 23).
  • 57% of complaint cases had at least one allegation resulting in an explanation being provided (table 23).

 


Reviews

The complainant has a right to apply for a review where a complaint has been recorded under Schedule 3 of the PRA 2002. They can apply for a review if they are unhappy with the way their complaint was handled, or with the outcome.

The application for review will be considered by the local policing body or the IOPC. The relevant review body depends on the circumstances of the complaint. The relevant review body will look at whether the handling and the outcome of the complaint was reasonable and proportionate.

There is no right of review against a complaint handled informally outside of Schedule 3. The complainant can request the complaint be recorded and handled formally if they are not satisfied with the outcome given to them. This will bring it inside the scope of Schedule 3 and, when the complaint is finalised, the complainant will get a right of review to the relevant review body.

Local policing body (LPB) reviews

In 2023/24, LPBs received 4,275 applications from complainants requesting a review of how their complaint had been handled or its final outcome. This is a small decrease from the 4,366 reviews received in 2022/23 (table 24).

  • The number of reviews LPBs received following complaints that had not been investigated was 3,845.
  • The number of reviews received following complaints that had been investigated was 430.

Outcome of LPB reviews

  • In 2023/24, 21% of reviews about complaints that were not investigated found the complaint handling or outcome was not reasonable and proportionate (table 25).
  • The proportion of non-investigation reviews that found the handling or outcome was not reasonable and proportionate varied considerably across police forces from 0% in three forces to 45% in Metropolitan Police (table 25).
  • 25% (99 out of 393) of the investigation reviews completed by LPBs found the complaint handling or outcome was not reasonable and proportionate (table 25).
  • The number of investigation reviews completed by LPBs varied considerably across forces. Only three LPBs completed ten or more reviews of police force investigations, the highest, by a considerable margin, being Thames Valley Police with 234 investigation reviews completed. Twenty-one LPBs completed no investigation reviews (table 25).

IOPC reviews

In 2023/24, the IOPC received 2,136 applications to review complaints dealt with by police forces, an increase of 7% on 2022/23 (table 26).

  • In 2023/24, the IOPC received 1,246 applications to review complaints not investigated by police forces.
  • The number of reviews received following complaints that had been investigated was 890.

Outcome of IOPC reviews

  • In 2023/24, the IOPC found that in 32% of complaints that had not been investigated,
    the complaint handling or outcome was not reasonable and proportionate  (table 27).
  • 33% (289 out of 864) of the investigation reviews completed by the IOPC found the complaint handling or outcome was not reasonable and proportionate (table 27).

 


Data considerations

This report only presents information about complaints handled under the new regime implemented 1 February 2020 and 4 January 2021 for the British Transport Police.


Hampshire Constabulary only started capturing information about complaints handled outside of Schedule 3 from February 2021. The flexibility in the new system means there will be different ways to handle complaints in a reasonable and proportionate manner. Some forces will choose to handle matters in a different way to other forces.


Figures for City of London include complaints about Action Fraud. Action Fraud is the UK’s national reporting centre for fraud and cybercrime. The service is run by the City of London Police, which is the national policing lead for economic crime.

Statistical notes

  • In the percentage columns presented in the following tables, ‘-’ denotes no data and ‘0’ denotes less than 0.5%.
  • Some percentages may add up to more or less than 100% due to rounding.
  • Average times are presented as working days and do not include weekends or bank holidays.
  • Complaint cases and allegations with invalid start/end dates have been removed from average time calculations. Therefore, the numbers of complaint cases and allegations used in the average time calculations may be lower than the total number of complaint cases and allegations finalised.

 


Data tables

Table 1: Number of complaint cases logged in 2023/24

Police forceNumber of complaint cases
Avon & Somerset2,646
Bedfordshire914
British Transport736
Cambridgeshire1,036
Cheshire1,545
City of London541
Cleveland1,993
Cumbria976
Derbyshire1,696
Devon & Cornwall1,550
Dorset1,502
Durham973
Dyfed-Powys884
Essex2,266
Gloucestershire1,260
Greater Manchester3,386
Gwent807
Hampshire3,524
Hertfordshire1,263
Humberside1,652
Kent2,089
Lancashire1,894
Leicestershire1,522
Lincolnshire1,169
Merseyside2,278
Metropolitan11,843
Norfolk334
North Wales599
North Yorkshire337
Northamptonshire1,316
Northumbria3,228
Nottinghamshire1,544
South Wales2,744
South Yorkshire1,651
Staffordshire1,743
Suffolk335
Surrey2,333
Sussex2,226
Thames Valley3,652
Warwickshire819
West Mercia1,939
West Midlands3,956
West Yorkshire3,383
Wiltshire1,374
Total85,458

The figures for City of London include complaint cases logged in relation to ‘Action Fraud’. Action Fraud is the UK’s national reporting centre for fraud and cybercrime. The service is run by the City of London Police, which is the national policing lead for economic crime.

 

Table 2: Number of complaint cases logged per 1,000 employees in 2023/24

Police forceNumber of complaint casesNumber of employees*Complaint cases per 1,000 employees
Avon & Somerset2,6466,710394
Bedfordshire9142,734334
British Transport7364,962148
Cambridgeshire1,0362,799370
Cheshire1,5454,204368
City of London5411,554348
Cleveland1,9932,454812
Cumbria9762,181448
Derbyshire1,6963,886436
Devon & Cornwall1,5506,829227
Dorset1,5022,900518
Durham9732,520386
Dyfed-Powys8842,257392
Essex2,2666,471350
Gloucestershire1,2602,739460
Greater Manchester3,38612,962261
Gwent8072,612309
Hampshire3,5245,747613
Hertfordshire1,2634,403287
Humberside1,6523,794435
Kent2,0897,081295
Lancashire1,8946,208305
Leicestershire1,5224,187364
Lincolnshire1,1692,354497
Merseyside2,2786,850333
Metropolitan11,84348,834243
Norfolk3343,48196
North Wales5993,080194
North Yorkshire3373,204105
Northamptonshire1,3162,747479
Northumbria3,2286,066532
Nottinghamshire1,5444,044382
South Wales2,7446,618415
South Yorkshire1,6515,583296
Staffordshire1,7433,765463
Suffolk3352,588129
Surrey2,3334,344537
Sussex2,2265,811383
Thames Valley3,6529,209397
Warwickshire8191,945421
West Mercia1,9394,456435
West Midlands3,95612,567315
West Yorkshire3,38310,722316
Wiltshire1,3742,490552
Total85,458252,952338

* “Number of employees” is taken from the Home Office publication Police Workforce, England and Wales, 31 March 2023.

 

Table 3: Time taken to log complaints and contact complainants in 2023/24

Police forceAverage days to log complaintsAverage number of days to contact complainants
Avon & Somerset59
Bedfordshire52
British Transport33
Cambridgeshire52
Cheshire12
City of London628
Cleveland11
Cumbria34
Derbyshire66
Devon & Cornwall3028
Dorset55
Durham42
Dyfed-Powys58
Essex1312
Gloucestershire117
Greater Manchester87
Gwent3314
Hampshire11
Hertfordshire21
Humberside15
Kent2012
Lancashire13
Leicestershire23
Lincolnshire123
Merseyside110
Metropolitan55
Norfolk38
North Wales38
North Yorkshire3916
Northamptonshire31
Northumbria35
Nottinghamshire67
South Wales410
South Yorkshire36
Staffordshire45
Suffolk38
Surrey13
Sussex89
Thames Valley24
Warwickshire11
West Mercia33
West Midlands212
West Yorkshire48
Wiltshire43
Total56

 

Table 4: Reasons complaint cases recorded under Schedule 3 in 2023/24

Police forceNature of allegation(s)Body responsible for initial handling decidesComplainant wishes the complaint to be recordedDissatisfaction after initial handlingTotal recorded under Schedule 3
N%N%N%N%
Avon & Somerset47537448352471911491,284
Bedfordshire13948682339134616292
British Transport57288743525226201
Cambridgeshire1003477262699031293
Cheshire12916353451231618023785
City of London1927304311202970
Cleveland931231825115143354
Cumbria732991372086526249
Derbyshire16517404422772912313969
Devon & Cornwall1271470379354243889
Dorset7611515767711142682
Durham165502131913340331
Dyfed-Powys6214291656314307446
Essex301,3779950001,385
Gloucestershire1962025970205416345
Greater Manchester245149845724414258151,731
Gwent12832116781812149
Hampshire48111723930718843438
Hertfordshire15341531432913336371
Humberside411615384275719306
Kent190139306260371251,497
Lancashire296487712174287412621
Leicestershire28425793712222421,123
Lincolnshire1115776955719323836
Merseyside73371617876136235
Metropolitan728172,278541,0472518244,235
Norfolk46181134551204116251
North Wales2160261667163234
North Yorkshire2711111478335167237
Northamptonshire1142585181413112026460
Northumbria57369 01571910613836
Nottinghamshire89224812561420351396
South Wales776414121,076561211,905
South Yorkshire7295206217321708835
Staffordshire127291673818412428436
Suffolk67251174443163814265
Surrey82136193154918529643
Sussex19286069585316251,253
Thames Valley1157301181,05962222131,697
Warwickshire2023384367242788
West Mercia8222158401111029379
West Midlands3975510915771113319716
West Yorkshire77962383564385311,258
Wiltshire5310347694496112505
Total6,9622113,962436,808214,7791532,511

 

Table 5: Number of allegations logged in 2023/24

Police forceNumber of allegationsNumber of employees*Allegations per 1,000 employees
Avon And Somerset5,1236,710763
Bedfordshire1,5202,734556
British Transport8784,962177
Cambridgeshire1,7172,799613
Cheshire2,4944,204593
City of London6511,554419
Cleveland3,0652,4541,249
Cumbria1,5972,181732
Derbyshire3,5463,886913
Devon And Cornwall3,0746,829450
Dorset2,3182,900799
Durham2,3752,520942
Dyfed-Powys1,1712,257519
Essex5,7056,471882
Gloucestershire2,2572,739824
Greater Manchester9,73612,962751
Gwent1,3802,612528
Hampshire4,7935,747834
Hertfordshire2,6224,403596
Humberside2,2163,794584
Kent4,4977,081635
Lancashire3,9886,208642
Leicestershire3,0824,187736
Lincolnshire2,0022,354850
Merseyside2,8056,850409
Metropolitan21,75948,834446
Norfolk1,1323,481325
North Wales1,1343,080368
North Yorkshire9643,204301
Northamptonshire2,2132,747806
Northumbria6,1936,0661,021
Nottinghamshire2,6044,044644
South Wales4,8736,618736
South Yorkshire3,5225,583631
Staffordshire2,7583,765733
Suffolk1,1082,588428
Surrey4,0184,344925
Sussex4,1635,811716
Thames Valley4,9319,209535
Warwickshire8501,945437
West Mercia2,3024,456517
West Midlands6,06712,567483
West Yorkshire4,18610,722390
Wiltshire2,1502,490863
Total151,539252,952599

The figures for City of London include complaint cases logged in relation to ‘Action Fraud’. Action Fraud is the UK’s national reporting centre for fraud and cybercrime. The service is run by the City of London Police, which is the national policing lead for economic crime.

*Number of employees is taken from the Home Office publication Police Workforce, England and Wales, 31 March 2023.

 

Table 6: Number of allegations logged - what has been complained about in 2023/24

Police forceDelivery of duties and servicePolice powers, policies and proceduresHandling of or damage to property/ premisesAccess and/or disclosure of informationUse of police vehiclesDiscriminatory behaviourAbuse of position/ corruptionIndividual behavioursSexual conductDiscreditable conductOtherTotal*
Avon & Somerset2,651872145968022316684593155,123
Bedfordshire7263585937148711193315171,520
British Transport3632712911262131175824878
Cambridgeshire77639565392654193314621,717
Cheshire1,176702844830465133861302,494
City of London447822061221251154651
Cleveland1,4577182385359261048316143,065
Cumbria7003407037393720318223111,597
Derbyshire1,90175710685456330464430613,546
Devon & Cornwall1,761679685314603337371883,074
Dorset1,0954521207429654640436242,318
Durham1,25162672313153328145182,375
Dyfed-Powys5872763741311421712911,171
Essex2,9961,0842299245221548981511605,705
Gloucestershire1,224494474733321929042652,257
Greater Manchester4,3422,421366237903251251,63832125359,736
Gwent842190283012121123701081,380
Hampshire2,5621,117127928892216381028184,793
Hertfordshire1,329482127462388204971902,622
Humberside1,246464528119162028434272,216
Kent2,1991,07155125112292225031533344,497
Lancashire2,21497773794210937389712493,988
Leicestershire1,47164511864251088954072133,082
Lincolnshire1,052503632828191127519132,002
Merseyside1,4596301386844682729827642,805
Metropolitan13,8124,144560274232719981,2065223043221,759
Norfolk48027529281139282391201,132
North Wales5522293029122844151313431,134
North Yorkshire3572333334149282023204964
Northamptonshire1,41340930631744122107622,213
Northumbria2,9691,25718719588150561,0969201656,192
Nottinghamshire1,42748365322538174391134322,603
South Wales2,22288621813260239127938632134,873
South Yorkshire2,01087540542282741326113,522
Staffordshire1,4976087530323614418215312,758
Suffolk4312803936846312350111,108
Surrey2,04582323310066107395131128534,018
Sussex1,8881,212788529144175289431304,163
Thames Valley2,8071,0021471126018077471614554,931
Warwickshire516973518131701226422850
West Mercia1,277461116444751426392372,302
West Midlands3,6691,1401828437190965771552256,067
West Yorkshire2,25994712710163261692811937224,186
Wiltshire1,086443763839662235651272,150
Total80,54432,4104,8363,0891,7584,5751,83819,5143241,0191,630151,537

*The number of allegations logged presented in this table are only those with a category recorded. Therefore they may not match the actual number of allegations logged presented in Table 5.

 

Table 7: Number of allegations logged - what has been complained about and subcategories in 2023/24

Allegation category

Delivery of duties and service

Allegation subcategoryN% of total allegations logged
Police action following contact33,90522
Decisions11,1277
General level of service27,02218
Information8,4846
No subcategory recorded20
Error in subcategories40
Police powers, policies and proceduresStops, and stop and search1,7551
Searches of premises and seizure of property4,0113
Power to arrest and detain5,4044
Detention in police custody4,4063
Bail, identification and interview procedures1,6941
Use of force8,5526
Evidential procedures2,5092
Out of court disposals5270
Other policies and procedures3,5452
No subcategory recorded30
Error in subcategories40
Handling of or damage to property/ premisesHandling of or damage to property/ premises4,6573
No subcategory recorded1770
Error in subcategories20
Access and/or disclosure of informationUse of police systems2430
Disclosure of information2,0841
Handling of information6170
Accessing and handling of information from other sources1440
Error in subcategories10
Use of police vehiclesUse of police vehicles1,7011
No subcategory recorded560
Error in subcategories10
Discriminatory behaviourAge730
Disability8381
Gender reassignment450
Marriage and civil partnership40
Pregnancy and maternity10
Race2,2792
Religion or belief1410
Sex6450
Sexual orientation1560
Other3930
Abuse of position/ corruptionAbuse of position for financial purpose590
Abuse of position for sexual purpose610
Abuse of position for the purpose of pursuing an inappropriate emotional relationship440
Abuse of position for other purpose4970
Obstruction of justice7921
Organisational corruption3850
Individual behavioursUnprofessional attitude and disrespect5,6044
Lack of fairness and impartiality2,6132
Overbearing or harassing behaviours3,5102
Impolite language / tone5,0353
Impolite and intolerant actions2,7512
No subcategory recorded10
Sexual conductSexual assault2270
Sexual harassment320
Other sexual conduct651
Discreditable conductDiscreditable conduct1,0161
No subcategory recorded30
OtherOther1,6301
Total allegations 151,537100

The number of allegations logged presented in this table are only those with a category recorded. Therefore they may not match the actual number of allegations logged presented in Table 5.

 

Table 8: Gender of complainants in 2023/24

GenderN%
Female32,16641
Male38,71949
Other2070
Prefer not to say1,5902
Unknown6,3598
Total79,041100

 

Table 9: Ethnicity of complainants in 2023/24

EthnicityN%
White43,91556
Black3,4064
Asian4,6736
Mixed1,6852
Other7151
Prefer not to say5,7977
Not stated17,09122
Unknown1,7592
Total79,041100

 

Table 10: Age of complainants in 2023/24

Age groupN%
17 or under1,4962
18-2911,16514
30-3917,18922
40-4915,45820
50-5912,70816
60+8,44411
Unknown12,58116
Total79,041100

Tables 8 to 10: Complainants are only counted once in these tables regardless of how many complaints they have made throughout the year.

Table 10: Complainant’s age data for allegations handled outside of Schedule 3 by Bedfordshire, Cambridgeshire and Hertfordshire is not available in 2023/24.

 

Table 11: Gender of those subject to a complaint in 2023/24

GenderN%
Female18,56533
Male34,51261
Other110
Prefer not to say290
Unknown3,2936
Total56,410100

 

Table 12: Ethnicity of those subject to a complaint in 2023/24

EthnicityN%
White45,15080
Black7671
Asian2,0104
Mixed8371
Other830
Prefer not to say5001
Not stated3,9077
Unknown3,1566
Total56,410100

Tables 11 and 12: Subjects are only counted once in these tables, regardless of how many complaints they have been subject to in the year.

Subjects’ demographic data is not recorded on Northumbria Police outside Schedule 3 complaints.

 

Table 13: Rank of those subject to a complaint in 2023/24

RankN%
Police officer ranks48,39085
Police staff4,8799
Community support officers9372
Contracted staff4591
Special constables4161
Unknown1,9963
Total57,077100

Table 13: The total number of subjects will not match the figures in tables 11 and 12. This is because people subject to more than one complaint in the year may have held different ranks at the time each allegation was logged. In such cases they will be counted more than once (for each rank).

 

Table 14: Means by which allegations were finalised in 2023/24

Police forceOutside of Schedule 3Under Schedule 3 - not investigatedUnder Schedule 3 - investigatedTotal
N%N%N%
Avon & Somerset1,650342,52052671144,841
Bedfordshire8004665638280161,736
British Transport6006825429303884
Cambridgeshire9375062533324171,886
Cheshire740311,4706217572,385
City of London3556995196212512
Cleveland1,94968862304422,855
Cumbria888546463911571,649
Derbyshire803242,4387310833,349
Devon & Cornwall578341,0286011161,717
Dorset846401,1105315472,110
Durham1,11763589336641,772
Dyfed-Powys42637651576361,140
Essex737152,877581,304274,918
Gloucestershire94449921485631,921
Greater Manchester3,012394,3975733747,746
Gwent7746119115308241,273
Hampshire3,567751,0672212134,755
Hertfordshire1,4155393735295112,647
Humberside1,56267690306532,317
Kent447102,696621,222284,365
Lancashire1,404362,10654403103,913
Leicestershire493182,1737714552,811
Lincolnshire355191,467779351,915
Merseyside2,019755672111242,698
Metropolitan8,182379,582434,4422022,206
Norfolk1321186875151131,151
North Wales365251,006689871,469
North Yorkshire2226446927029936
Northamptonshire1,0844893641255112,275
Northumbria2,8925924651,745364,883
Nottinghamshire1,4275489134315122,633
South Wales936252,5246825273,712
South Yorkshire1,020312,240684113,301
Staffordshire1,609571,116408932,814
Suffolk124146247113715885
Surrey1,622431,9765219253,790
Sussex1,229302,782687924,090
Thames Valley1,984368623,492635,562
Warwickshire598834367911720
West Mercia1,82270740283912,601
West Midlands3,760661,7963115135,707
West Yorkshire2,121531,6714221754,009
Wiltshire819468284615281,799
Total60,1664263,6324518,86013142,658

 

Table 15: Time taken to finalise allegations in 2023/24

Police forceAverage number of days to finalise allegations outside of Schedule 3Average number of days to finalise allegations - not investigated under Schedule 3Average number of days to finalise allegations - by local investigation under Schedule 3
Avon & Somerset1397190
Bedfordshire6377216
British Transport1334198
Cambridgeshire1872186
Cheshire2173125
City of London87158175
Cleveland14104215
Cumbria25135167
Derbyshire1194204
Devon & Cornwall45138324
Dorset2580183
Durham1295242
Dyfed-Powys1562167
Essex1785170
Gloucestershire34148223
Greater Manchester2580248
Gwent33110191
Hampshire679253
Hertfordshire777200
Humberside1388107
Kent1486152
Lancashire6336361
Leicestershire1245145
Lincolnshire1369141
Merseyside1689183
Metropolitan16157229
Norfolk51139221
North Wales1693253
North Yorkshire36146205
Northamptonshire8118238
Northumbria18104131
Nottinghamshire1697172
South Wales1192221
South Yorkshire1563195
Staffordshire1182198
Suffolk59133259
Surrey1393264
Sussex1944177
Thames Valley6128152
Warwickshire2585139
West Mercia34169265
West Midlands2079244
West Yorkshire674121
Wiltshire44122299
Total18106191

Only allegations with valid dates are used in the calculation for the average number of days to finalise allegations.

 

Table 16: Allegations finalised by investigation under Schedule 3 in 2023/24

Police forceInvestigated (not subject to special procedures)Investigated (subject to special procedures)
N%N%
Avon & Somerset596897511
Bedfordshire2719793
British Transport17571343
Cambridgeshire29892268
Cheshire16494116
City of London5385915
Cleveland439812
Cumbria104901110
Derbyshire1069822
Devon & Cornwall96861514
Dorset1499753
Durham40612639
Dyfed-Powys50791321
Essex1,28699181
Gloucestershire24433257
Greater Manchester254758325
Gwent28894206
Hampshire90743126
Hertfordshire27192248
Humberside48741726
Kent1,18897343
Lancashire38495195
Leicestershire119822618
Lincolnshire899644
Merseyside84752825
Metropolitan3,6058183719
Norfolk14193107
North Wales68693031
North Yorkshire242902810
Northamptonshire210824518
Northumbria1,72699191
Nottinghamshire240767524
South Wales2459773
South Yorkshire3278922
Staffordshire74831517
Suffolk12591129
Surrey109578343
Sussex26335367
Thames Valley3,40598872
Warwickshire69871013
West Mercia3282718
West Midlands121803020
West Yorkshire194892311
Wiltshire125822718
Total16,901901,95910

 

Table 17: Nature of allegations finalised outside of Schedule 3 in 2023/24

Allegation categoryAllegation subcategoryN% of total allegations finalised outside of Schedule 3
Delivery of duties and servicePolice action following contact17,18129
Decisions4,6298
General level of service14,08323
Information3,1695
No subcategory recorded10
Error in subcategories30
Police powers, policies and proceduresStops, and stop and search6611
Searches of premises and seizure of property1,6113
Power to arrest and detain1,2942
Detention in police custody5461
Bail, identification and interview procedures4441
Use of force1,2452
Evidential procedures5771
Out of court disposals2640
Other policies and procedures1,3312
No subcategory recorded30
Error in subcategories30
Handling of or damage to property/premisesHandling of or damage to property/premises2,3624
No subcategory recorded1840
Error in subcategories20
Access and/or disclosure of informationUse of police systems700
Disclosure of information5451
Handling of information2140
Accessing and handling of information from other sources450
Error in subcategories10
Use of police vehiclesUse of police vehicles1,1022
No subcategory recorded610
Error in subcategories10
Discriminatory behaviourAge160
Disability1090
Gender reassignment50
Pregnancy and maternity10
Race2600
Religion or belief200
Sex750
Sexual orientation140
Other470
Abuse of position/corruptionAbuse of position for financial purpose130
Abuse of position for sexual purpose100
Abuse of position for the purpose of pursuing an inappropriate emotional relationship10
Abuse of position for other purpose620
Obstruction of justice250
Organisational corruption310
Individual behavioursUnprofessional attitude and disrespect2,0163
Lack of fairness and impartiality6111
Overbearing or harassing behaviours9772
Impolite language / tone2,2044
Impolite and intolerant actions1,0812
No subcategory recorded10
Sexual conductSexual assault160
Sexual harassment5-
Other sexual conduct80
Discreditable conductDiscreditable conduct1250
No subcategory recordedNo subcategory recorded30
OtherOther7961
Total allegations 60,166100

 

Table 18: Nature of allegations finalised under Schedule 3 by how they were handled in 2023/24

Allegation categoryAllegation subcategoryNot investigatedInvestigatedTotal number of allegations finalised under Schedule 3
N% of total number finalised under Schedule 3N% of total number finalised under Schedule 3
Delivery of duties and servicePolice action following contact12,517152,376314,893
Decisions4,80061,05315,853
General level of service9,749122,683312,432
Information3,887572414,611
No subcategory recorded10001
Police powers, policies and proceduresStops, and stop and search733134301,076
Searches of premises and seizure of property1,707245512,162
Power to arrest and detain2,713391513,628
Detention in police custody2,598393113,529
Bail, identification and interview procedures81411710985
Use of force4,26152,26536,526
Evidential procedures1,345234201,687
Out of court disposals1950390234
Other policies and procedures1,515244511,960
No subcategory recorded10001
Error in subcategories00101
Handling of or damage to property/premisesHandling of or damage to property/premises1,583240101,984
Access and/or disclosure of informationUse of police systems870680155
Disclosure of information1,020137201,392
Handling of information3070800387
Accessing and handling of information from other sources53042095
Use of police vehiclesUse of police vehicles39901300529
Discriminatory behaviourAge22016038
Disability45411950649
Gender reassignment18010028
Marriage and civil partnership10102
Pregnancy and maternity00101
Race1,331265111,982
Religion or belief59034093
Sex40301260529
Sexual orientation850280113
Other2250730298
Abuse of position/ corruptionAbuse of position for financial purpose23022045
Abuse of position for sexual purpose14048062
Abuse of position for the purpose of pursuing an inappropriate emotional relationship4018022
Abuse of position for other purpose19401400334
Obstruction of justice45813020760
Organisational corruption2370730310
Individual behavioursUnprofessional attitude and disrespect2,460379413,254
Lack of fairness and impartiality1,398237801,776
Overbearing or harassing behaviours1,690260312,293
Impolite language / tone2,090342612,516
Impolite and intolerant actions1,204134301,547
Sexual conductSexual assault730990172
Sexual harassment1006016
Other sexual conduct18040058
Discreditable conductDiscreditable conduct32003660686
OtherOther55612310787
Total allegations 63,6327718,6602382,492

 

Table 19: Decisions on allegations by how they were handled in 2023/24

Allegation decisionOutside of Schedule 3Under Schedule 3 – not investigatedUnder Schedule 3 – investigated (not subject to special procedures)Under Schedule 3 – investigated (subject to special procedures)
N%N%N%N%
Not resolved4,1027      
Resolved56,06293      
Service provided - acceptable  42,7946712,0547144323
Service provided - not acceptable  8,389132,01412864
Service provided - unable to determine  5,111814629593
No further action  5,1168703490
Withdrawal  2,06034863392
Regulation 41 applies  1620181150
No case to answer      81842
Case to answer      50026
Total60,16410063,63210016,9001001,959100

The number of allegations presented in this table may not match the totals in Table 14. This is due to a small number of finalised allegations which had recorded decisions incompatible with the way they were handled. These have been excluded from the totals.

 

Table 20: Number of complaint cases finalised in 2023/24

Police forceOutside of Schedule 3Under Schedule 3Total number of complaint cases
NNN
Avon & Somerset1,3331,0312,364
Bedfordshire7373631,100
British Transport582214796
Cambridgeshire7623791,141
Cheshire7107901,500
City of London30696402
Cleveland1,5043481,852
Cumbria654267921
Derbyshire6571,0231,680
Devon & Cornwall441469910
Dorset7556631,418
Durham631220851
Dyfed-Powys407469876
Essex7341,3632,097
Gloucestershire7742931,067
Greater Manchester1,7161,6233,339
Gwent652132784
Hampshire2,9804153,395
Hertfordshire8934391,332
Humberside1,3694781,847
Kent4101,3431,753
Lancashire1,2557502,005
Leicestershire3871,0471,434
Lincolnshire3388291,167
Merseyside1,9392602,199
Metropolitan7,8123,88311,695
Norfolk81332413
North Wales363279642
North Yorkshire16203219
Northamptonshire8414441,285
Northumbria2,1097662,875
Nottinghamshire1,0544681,522
South Wales7651,4722,237
South Yorkshire8288571,685
Staffordshire1,2904481,738
Suffolk74254328
Surrey1,5256602,185
Sussex9271,2922,219
Thames Valley1,9231,6333,556
Warwickshire570100670
West Mercia1,6205262,146
West Midlands3,1306983,828
West Yorkshire2,0621,0343,096
Wiltshire6785291,207
Total50,59431,18281,776

 

Table 21: Time taken to finalise complaint cases in 2023/24

Police forceNumber of valid complaint cases finalised outside of Schedule 3*Average number of days to finalise outside of Schedule 3Number of valid complaint cases finalised under of Schedule 3*Average number of days to finalise under of Schedule 3 (inc suspension)Average number of days to finalise under of Schedule 3 (exc suspension)
Avon And Somerset1,333131,031135131
Bedfordshire73766363130126
British Transport578492146561
Cambridgeshire76217379138134
Cheshire710227908575
City of London3069796204199
Cleveland1,5041434810897
Cumbria65426267125111
Derbyshire657121,023126125
Devon And Cornwall44159469243230
Dorset7552966311088
Durham631132209884
Dyfed-Powys40718469111109
Essex734171,363143134
Gloucestershire77436293193169
Greater Manchester1,716281,623148146
Gwent65234132135126
Hampshire2,9807415118108
Hertfordshire8936439135127
Humberside1,3691547810391
Kent410181,343105101
Lancashire1,2557750341335
Leicestershire387121,0477164
Lincolnshire33813829117116
Merseyside1,93917260113100
Metropolitan7,810193,883211208
Norfolk8153332171144
North Wales3631827910196
North Yorkshire1655203246245
Northamptonshire8419444152143
Northumbria2,08517766159150
Nottinghamshire1,0541846812399
South Wales765131,47210199
South Yorkshire828168578985
Staffordshire1,2901544810898
Suffolk7444254154124
Surrey1,52514660112106
Sussex926191,2926762
Thames Valley1,92371,633147139
Warwickshire57026100146133
West Mercia1,62036526178168
West Midlands3,13027698127121
West Yorkshire2,06261,03410997
Wiltshire67845529141122
Total50,5632031,182140133

*The number of complaint cases presented in this table are only those with valid dates that are used in the calculation for the average number of days to finalise complaint cases. Therefore they may not match the actual number of complaint cases finalised presented in Table 20.

Table 22: Actions on complaint cases handled outside of Schedule 3 in 2023/24

ActionNumberAs a % of complaint cases finalised
Organisational learning1670
Learning from reflection1,3463
Policy/procedure review470
Goodwill gesture1010
Apology4,82610
Debrief of original incident4371
Explanation provided29,82659
No further action6,96414

Actions are captured at allegation level and multiple actions can be selected on a single allegation. The figures in the table are based on complaint cases finalised in the year with at least one allegation that resulted in the corresponding action.

Not all of the available actions arising from the complaint handling are shown. The actions presented in the table are those that focus on putting the issue right and preventing it from happening again.

 

Table 23: Actions on complaint cases handled under Schedule 3 in 2023/24

ActionNumberAs a % of complaint cases finalised
Organisational learning6482
Learning from reflection3,40411
Policy/procedure review310
Goodwill gesture230
Apology1,8226
Debrief of original incident3781
Explanation provided17,81557
Referral to RPRP8813
Unsatisfactory Performance Procedure (UPP)280
Misconduct proceedings1410
Other actions following a case to answer decision200
Other action7352
No further action9,45830

Actions are captured at allegation level and multiple actions can be selected on a single allegation. The figures in the table are based on complaint cases finalised in the year with at least one allegation that resulted in the corresponding action.


Not all of the available actions arising from the complaint handling are shown. The actions presented in the table are those that focus on putting the issue right and preventing it from happening again.
 

Table 24: Applications for a review received by LPBs in 2023/24

Police forceLPB reviews – not investigatedLPB reviews - investigationTotal LPB reviews received
N%N%N
Avon & Somerset1479753152
Bedfordshire521000-52
British Transport2166113432
Cambridgeshire47981248
Cheshire1049822106
City of London11000-1
Cleveland681000-68
Cumbria421000-42
Derbyshire771000-77
Devon & Cornwall1129911113
Dorset1099654114
Durham371000-37
Dyfed-Powys631000-63
Essex1011000-101
Gloucestershire371000-37
Greater Manchester2409921242
Gwent237962129
Hampshire731000-73
Hertfordshire531000-53
Humberside97991198
Kent1999921201
Lancashire341000-34
Leicestershire1421000-142
Lincolnshire1041000-104
Merseyside67991168
Metropolitan42496184442
Norfolk42933745
North Wales321000-32
North Yorkshire498961155
Northamptonshire74991175
Northumbria89859193
Nottinghamshire1039555108
South Wales76945681
South Yorkshire981000-98
Staffordshire711000-71
Suffolk291000-29
Surrey1249911125
Sussex2181000-218
Thames Valley6224898254
Warwickshire936166425
West Mercia991000-99
West Midlands731000-73
West Yorkshire1959911196
Wiltshire65944669
Total3,84590430104,275

 

Table 25: Outcome of reviews completed by LPBs in 2023/24

Police forceLPB reviews - not investigatedLPB reviews - investigation
Valid completedHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateValid completedHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionate
NN%N% 
Avon And Somerset14633235120
Bedfordshire47360--
British Transport1816900
Cambridgeshire41922100
Cheshire97662150
City of London1000--
Cleveland7017240--
Cumbria3412350--
Derbyshire818100--
Devon And Cornwall753648200
Dorset982222400
Durham3439100
Dyfed-Powys596100--
Essex467150--
Gloucestershire3313390--
Greater Manchester40712531200
Gwent18007114
Hampshire568140--
Hertfordshire5971211100
Humberside1031616100
Kent1513020200
Lancashire416150--
Leicestershire148640--
Lincolnshire10728260--
Merseyside66711100
Metropolitan335151458225
Norfolk38821300
North Wales304130--
North Yorkshire3318550--
Northamptonshire7019270--
Northumbria700842429
Nottinghamshire962021300
South Wales671522400
South Yorkshire9127300--
Staffordshire7610130--
Suffolk33260--
Surrey121121011100
Sussex21630140--
Thames Valley72292346126
Warwickshire822513754
West Mercia105770--
West Midlands8122270--
West Yorkshire2023115100
Wiltshire60712400
Total3,712796213939925

Some caution is advised when looking at the percentage of reviews that found the complaint case outcome was not reasonable and proportionate due to the sometimes small number of reviews involved.

 

Table 26: Applications for a review received by the IOPC in 2023/24

Police forceIOPC reviews – not investigatedIOPC reviews - investigationTotal 
N%N%N
Avon and Somerset2747305357
Bedfordshire2252204842
British Transport0061006
Cambridgeshire1341195932
Cheshire257872232
City of London2403605
Cleveland1332673
Cumbria105974117
Derbyshire840126020
Devon and Cornwall5280132065
Dorset116173918
Durham156583523
Dyfed-Powys76443611
Essex59515749116
Gloucestershire96943113
Greater Manchester6371262989
Gwent0021002
Hampshire6285111573
Hertfordshire1853164734
Humberside115884219
Kent2126597480
Lancashire1757134330
Leicestershire348181942
Lincolnshire115594520
Merseyside1858134231
Metropolitan2845424346527
Norfolk1959134132
North Wales348751339
North Yorkshire32787311
Northamptonshire105394719
Northumbria1114698680
Nottinghamshire2227789
South Wales80703430114
South Yorkshire45943648
Staffordshire136863219
Suffolk196893228
Surrey65065012
Sussex43386712
Thames Valley13309731
Warwickshire1146867
West Mercia0021002
West Midlands8183171798
West Yorkshire97713929136
Wiltshire2063123832
Total1,24658890422,136

 

Table 27: Outcome of reviews completed by the IOPC in 2023/24

Police forceIOPC reviews - not investigatedIOPC reviews - investigation
Valid completedHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateValid completedHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionateHandling or outcome not reasonable and proportionate
NN%NN%
Avon And Somerset2383531516
Bedfordshire2021023626
British Transport00-4250
Cambridgeshire1942117529
Cheshire2552010440
City of London20011100
Cleveland00-4125
Cumbria64676350
Derbyshire933312433
Devon And Cornwall69294217635
Dorset1475013431
Durham2110487343
Dyfed-Powys113276117
Essex792329673045
Gloucestershire112184250
Greater Manchester483165221045
Gwent00-3133
Hampshire65132011545
Hertfordshire1033016425
Humberside2052511436
Kent24938691725
Lancashire1564010330
Leicestershire3651413323
Lincolnshire1353813215
Merseyside2583211436
Metropolitan22963281685633
Norfolk2713487229
North Wales303103267
North Yorkshire52407457
Northamptonshire2173313323
Northumbria11436922224
Nottinghamshire215012217
South Wales742230321238
South Yorkshire4814299222
Staffordshire2462510330
Suffolk186336350
Surrey61176350
Sussex313310660
Thames Valley00-25832
Warwickshire111006350
West Mercia00-00-
West Midlands78344418844
West Yorkshire863440341853
Wiltshire264155240
Total12544013286428933

Some reviews may be deemed ‘invalid’ and these have been excluded from the number of 'valid completed' and the calculation for '% outcome not reasonable and proportionate'.


Some caution is advised when looking at the percentage of reviews that found the complaint case outcome was not reasonable and proportionate due to the sometimes small number of reviews involved.


Outcome not reasonable and proportionate on reviews not investigated differs slightly to the bulletins due to an updated outcome

 


Glossary

Allegation

This describes what is being complained about. An allegation is made by someone defined as a complainant under the Police Reform Act 2002 (see ‘complainant’). An allegation may be made by one or more complainants about the service they received from a police force. For example, about force-wide crime initiatives, organisation of policing resources, or general policing standards. However, it can also be about the conduct of any person serving with the police.

A complaint case may involve more than one allegation. For example, a person may allege that an officer pushed and was rude to them. This would be logged as two separate allegations forming one complaint case. Each allegation is logged against a specific category (a full list of the allegation categories and their definitions can be found in the IOPC’s Guidance on capturing data  about police complaints).

Appropriate authority

(Section 29, Police Reform Act 2002)

The organisation responsible for assessing how to deal with a complaint. For example, whether it can be handled locally or reaches the criteria for referral to the IOPC. The appropriate authority may be the chief officer of the police force or the police and crime commissioner for the force. If a complaint investigation finds someone has a case to answer for misconduct, the appropriate authority is responsible for arranging any misconduct proceedings. If you make a complaint, the appropriate authority for your case will contact you.
 

Complainant

A person who makes a complaint about the conduct of someone serving with the police or about a police force. The law sets out the circumstances that need to exist for someone to make a complaint (see section 5.6 of the IOPC Statutory guidance on the police complaints system).

Complaint

A complaint is any expression of dissatisfaction raised by or on behalf of a member of the public to a police force. A complaint does not have to be made in writing and does not have to state explicitly that it is a complaint.

Complaint case

A complaint may involve more than one allegation. The allegation/s may be made by one or more complainants, against one or more
persons serving with the police. ‘Complaint case’ refers to all the allegations and complainants connected with a complaint.

Directed investigation

An investigation conducted by the appropriate authority under the direction and control of the IOPC. The IOPC directs the investigation by appointing an investigator and setting out its scope and investigative strategy. The IOPC controls the investigation by reviewing the policy books, confirming the investigation has met the terms of reference and making the decisions at the end of the case.
 

Independent investigation

An investigation carried out by IOPC staff (Paragraph 19, Schedule 3, Police Reform Act 2002).

An independent investigation is often used for the most serious incidents and/or those with the greatest public interest. For example, incidents that cause the greatest level of public concern, have a high potential to impact on communities, or have serious implications for the reputation of the police service.

Local investigation

An investigation carried out by the appropriate authority on its own behalf (Paragraph 16, Schedule 3, Police Reform Act 2002).

Local policing body

The body responsible for all policing in their area. It holds the chief constable and the force to account. This is a collective term for:

  • Police and Crime Commissioners
  • the Mayor’s Office for Policing and Crime (for the Metropolitan Police Service district)
  • the Common Council (for the City of London police area) (Section 101, Police Act 1996)

Reflective practice review process (RPRP)

This focuses on putting an issue right and preventing it from happening again by encouraging those involved to reflect on their actions and learn from them. It is not a disciplinary process or a disciplinary outcome.

Review

Where a complaint has been recorded under Schedule 3 to the Police Reform Act 2002, the complainant has a right to apply for a review of the outcome of the complaint. The review will consider whether the outcome of the handling of the complaint is reasonable and proportionate. It will uphold the review where the relevant review body finds that the outcome of the complaint is not reasonable and proportionate. This applies whether the complaint has been investigated or handled in another way.

Special procedures

Special procedures only apply to investigations of complaints about a member of a police force or a special constable. In the case of any other person, the investigator must adhere to the relevant policies and procedures for investigating allegations of any form of misconduct.

Investigators must apply special procedures:

  • in a complaint investigation, when there is an indication a person being investigated may have committed a criminal offence or behaved in a manner that would justify disciplinary proceedings
  • in all investigations into recordable conduct matters (Paragraph 19A, Schedule 3, Police Reform Act 2002)

Unsatisfactory performance procedure (UPP)

A series of steps used to improve someone’s performance. It is used when a person was unable or failed to perform their role to a satisfactory level but did not breach the Standards of Professional Behaviour.

 

Back to top.